admin
New Yorkers were sold a fantasy: freeze the rent, get free buses, universal childcare and government-run groceries — all without ever having to open their wallets. That fairy tale is cracking now that Zohran Mamdani is discovering what every real mayor learns the hard way: promises cost money and the city can’t conjure cash from slogans.
The harsh math is staring him down. A rental-voucher program he championed grew from a modest pilot to a billion-dollar line item, and experts estimate a full expansion would run into the tens of billions over several years — at a time when the city is wrestling with a multibillion-dollar shortfall.
So what does Mamdani do when the free-lunch bill comes due? He trots out familiar left-wing remedies: hike taxes on the wealthy and squeeze corporations until they “pay their share,” even proposing a two-percentage-point surtax on the top one percent and a corporate rate jump to match New Jersey. Voters who thought affordability meant smaller bills are now being told to accept bigger bills for everyone else instead.
Republican Rep. Mike Lawler didn’t mince words on this hypocrisy, reminding Americans that socialism runs aground when you run out of “other people’s money.” Lawler warned that Mamdani’s agenda, if unchecked, will accelerate the exodus from New York and punish the very small businesses and middle-class homeowners the mayor claims to help.
This isn’t just partisan chest-thumping — economists and watchdogs say rental subsidies can boost demand and push prices higher unless supply is increased, and expensive voucher expansions haven’t shown the promised shelter reductions. If the answer to failing programs is more taxes and more control, New Yorkers will pay with higher costs, fewer jobs, and a lower standard of living.
Political posturing is already trumping practical governance: Mamdani reportedly even considered backing away from a high-profile “tax the rich” rally to avoid alienating other power players, a sign that his radical proposals clash with political reality. Conservatives should use this moment to expose the disconnect between left-wing promises and fiscal consequences, and to insist on policies that expand housing supply and protect taxpayers.
The real victims of this smoke-and-mirrors politics will be ordinary New Yorkers — homeowners and renters alike — who face higher assessments and an economy burdened by fleeing businesses. If Mamdani moves from campaign rhetoric to real tax hikes and intrusive control, the city will get poorer, not fairer, and hardworking Americans must demand common-sense solutions over socialist experiments.
