Staff Reports
Disney’s live-action remake of Snow White has become a lightning rod for controversy, reflecting the pitfalls of modernizing beloved classics with overt political messaging. The film, which aimed to reimagine the 1937 animated masterpiece, has struggled to resonate with audiences and critics alike. With a disappointing $87 million global opening against a staggering $270 million production budget, Snow White is shaping up to be one of Disney’s most significant missteps in recent years. The backlash surrounding the film highlights growing frustration among viewers who feel that Disney’s progressive agenda is overshadowing the timeless charm and storytelling that once defined its legacy.
Central to the controversy is lead actress Rachel Zegler, whose comments about the original story being outdated and sexist alienated many fans before the film’s release. Zegler dismissed the classic narrative of Snow White dreaming of true love and being saved by a prince, instead emphasizing themes of leadership and independence. While these changes were intended to appeal to modern audiences, they have been criticized as heavy-handed and disconnected from the essence of the fairy tale. Zegler’s remarks, coupled with her political activism—including pro-Palestinian statements—fueled conservative backlash, further complicating the film’s reception.
The casting decisions also sparked debate, particularly Zegler’s portrayal of Snow White, which deviated from the character’s traditional depiction in both appearance and personality. Critics argued that Disney prioritized diversity over fidelity to the source material, echoing complaints from previous adaptations like The Little Mermaid. Additionally, Gal Gadot’s role as the Evil Queen drew criticism due to her vocal support for Israel following Hamas’ attacks in 2023, creating tension between her and Zegler’s opposing political views. These controversies overshadowed the film itself, leaving audiences divided before it even hit theaters.
Critically, Snow White has fared poorly, earning a dismal 43% score on Rotten Tomatoes and a B+ CinemaScore—the lowest audience grade for a Disney live-action remake. Reviews have slammed its muddled tone, unsettling CGI dwarfs, and overtly political themes. The film’s attempts to incorporate modern social commentary have been described as forced and distracting, undermining its ability to deliver an engaging cinematic experience. For many viewers, this departure from Disney’s tradition of magical storytelling felt more like a lecture than entertainment.
The failure of Snow White serves as a cautionary tale for Disney as it grapples with declining box office returns and growing dissatisfaction among its core audience. While progressive narratives may appeal to certain demographics, they risk alienating families seeking escapism and nostalgia. If Disney hopes to regain its footing, it must prioritize storytelling that honors its heritage rather than bending classics to fit contemporary political ideologies. The lesson is clear: audiences want enchantment—not activism—in their fairy tales.
