Staff Reports
In recent news, it’s been discussed that if former President Donald Trump were still in charge, Russia might not have invaded Ukraine. Many people believe this, including Trump himself. He’s keen on stopping the fighting and has suggested ways to help Ukraine’s economy, like a rare metals deal with America. The details of this deal are still being figured out, but Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky didn’t like the early plan, which led to some disagreements with Trump. This situation shows that Ukraine is careful about who they trust and why.
Ukraine is being cautious because of its past experiences. Before Russia’s invasions in 2014 and 2022, many big American companies set up shop in Ukraine, thinking they could help the country grow. However, when the fighting started, these companies had to leave or shrink their operations. This made Ukraine realize that having strong economic ties doesn’t always protect them from attacks. So, when Trump offered the rare metals deal without any solid security guarantees, Zelensky was right to be hesitant.
The US-proposed draft contract reportedly requires Ukraine to cede half its revenue from rare earth minerals — without security guarantees.
Ukraine’s critical mineral reserves are vital for global tech and defence industries, yet some are under Russian control pic.twitter.com/wsEspoCsTl
— TRT World (@trtworld) February 25, 2025
The history of American companies in Ukraine reveals a pattern: when conflict arises, these companies can’t always stay and help. During the 2014 invasion, some American businesses had to close or move to safer areas. In 2022, the situation got worse, showing that economic connections can’t always fend off aggression. Zelensky understands this well and wants assurances that Ukraine will be protected in the long term, no matter who is in charge in America.
The ongoing negotiations between Ukraine and the U.S. are crucial for both parties. Zelensky’s caution isn’t about disrespecting Trump but about ensuring that any agreement will truly keep Ukraine safe in the future. The past has taught Ukraine that promises of economic support alone aren’t enough when facing war. Zelensky’s skepticism is a result of years of disappointment and broken trust.
Ultimately, Ukraine’s stance on the rare metals pact reflects a desire for lasting peace and security. While economic partnerships can be beneficial, they must come with guarantees that go beyond political changes. Zelensky’s reservations are grounded in a harsh reality: without a strong defense pact, Ukraine remains vulnerable to future aggression. It is important for America to understand and respect Ukraine’s concerns as they navigate these critical negotiations.
