When the College Football Playoff’s executive director, Rich Clark, told reporters that publishing the selection committee’s internal grading metrics “isn’t feasible,” he didn’t calm a single angry fan. He handed them a reason to be louder. The comment came after the committee released a controversial top‑25 that left Alabama above Tennessee despite Tennessee’s head‑to‑head win. That one line — “not feasible” — now sits at the center of a debate about fairness, accountability, and who gets to decide which teams play for championships in a multi‑billion‑dollar sport.
What Rich Clark actually said — and why it matters
At a media availability after the latest rankings, Rich Clark explained the committee has not provided its metrics publicly and that there are “so many metrics” that explaining them wouldn’t be feasible right now. He did say the CFP is “considering” how to present metrics in the offseason. That sounds like bureaucratic foot‑dragging dressed up as realism. Fans, coaches, and athletic directors don’t want mysteries; they want a transparent process that explains how head‑to‑head wins, schedules, and conference championships are weighed.
Transparency or protectionism?
Let’s be blunt: when a process that sets postseason fates stays secret, people assume the worst. When Alabama sits at No. 3 while Tennessee — which beat them — sits much lower, the optics are terrible. The committee’s secrecy invites charges of favoritism and fuels conspiracy theories that the math is being cooked. If the metrics are too messy for public consumption, that’s on the CFP, not on the public. You can’t run a national championship selection like a behind‑closed‑doors country club and then expect everyone to be satisfied.
Expansion makes accountability urgent
Next season’s move to a 24‑team field raises the stakes. More teams will be affected by seeding and at‑large choices, and more TV money and institutional prestige will hang on those calls. If the CFP wants public trust, it needs public rules. The choice to hide the numbers now looks less like practicality and more like a way to avoid having to defend decisions when the noise gets loud — which it already has. The committee’s chair and members shouldn’t wait for lawsuits or congressional curiosity to force a disclosure they should make on their own.
How the CFP should fix this — and fast
The remedy is simple: publish the metrics, publish examples, and give the public a plain‑English explanation. If the full internal model is complex, release a redacted or simplified version that shows how head‑to‑head results, strength of schedule, conference titles, and game film input into rankings. Offer sample calculations — show how Alabama and Tennessee were scored. Set a clear offseason timeline for these changes and allow independent audits of the process. If the CFP won’t do that voluntarily, then athletic directors and fans should demand it loudly. After all, when billions and championships are at stake, “not feasible” shouldn’t cut it as an answer.
