President—sorry, former President—Joe Biden’s new memoir, Promise Me, America, drops a juicy claim: he says Governor Gavin Newsom and others quietly took their names out of the running for the 2024 Democratic nomination so they wouldn’t risk alienating Black voters or triggering a walkout by “prominent Black women” in the party. That passage has set off a new round of finger-pointing inside the party and lit up conservative talk shows. If true, it is a pretty blunt confession about how identity politics can shape who gets to run for the highest office.
Biden’s account: “They would have walked out”
In the memoir Biden recounts that longtime strategist Donna Brazile and other Black party leaders warned that a contested fight could be seen as an attempt to block the first Black woman on a major ticket, and that these warnings convinced some potential candidates to stand down. The most notable names Biden mentions are Governor Gavin Newsom of California and Governor Gretchen Whitmer of Michigan. Biden writes that some took their names “out of the running preemptively” to avoid ripping the party apart. That is a big claim coming straight from his own pages.
Newsom’s version — canned, careful, and a little different
Newsom’s camp has been careful. His office declined to comment specifically on Biden’s passage, and Newsom himself has repeatedly said his 2024 calculus was more complicated than a single explanation. He has also told interviewers he wouldn’t run if Former Vice President Kamala Harris runs — a line that could be read either as deference or as political strategy. Bottom line: Biden’s memoir tells one story; public statements and spokespeople offer something closer to “we’ll leave the messy talk to the book tour.” Take both with a grain of skepticism.
Why this matters: the power of identity politics
Here’s the uncomfortable question: if the Democratic Party will effectively clear the field for candidates based primarily on race or gender, what does that say about merit, competition, and who gets to be president? Democrats like to invoke unity, but unity achieved by arm-twisting and identity calculations is still control. Biden’s memoir passage reads like a confession that the party values optics and identity coalitions more than open competition. For voters on both sides, that should be concerning.
Memoirs sell best when they reshuffle blame and tidy up memories. Biden’s account will be read as another effort to explain away the 2024 collapse and to defend his choices. But authority matters: if party leaders can pressure potential rivals to step aside because of their skin color or gender, the voters lose. Watch for Newsom, Whitmer, and Donna Brazile to answer on the record — and don’t expect the answers to be identical. Until then, the takeaway is plain: in today’s Democratic Party, identity politics isn’t an argument, it’s a veto. That’s the real story Biden’s book accidentally confirmed.

