admin
Seattle’s new mayor and city attorney just unveiled a plan that sounds good in a press release: use “red flag” laws to take guns from alleged pimps and traffickers on Aurora Avenue. It is a flashy idea meant to show action after residents put up planters and demanded safety. But fancy headlines don’t fix a broken street or a broken system. This move raises real legal and public‑safety questions, and it risks doing more harm than good.
What the city announced
Mayor Katie Wilson and City Attorney Erika Evans said the city will step up patrols, replace makeshift barriers with traffic‑calming measures, and push for new authority to close streets when needed. The sharpest new idea is a request to fund a prosecutor who would file Extreme Risk Protection Orders (ERPOs) — the so‑called red‑flag orders — to remove guns from people the city says are tied to trafficking. The pitch is that ERPOs are a civil tool that can work when criminal convictions are hard to get.
Why using ERPOs against traffickers is the wrong tool
Due process and practical problems
ERPOs were made for clear, imminent risks — someone threatening to hurt themselves or others. Stretching that law to target people because they’re accused of arranging prostitution or running a trafficking ring is untested and risky. Who proves the person is a trafficker? What evidence will judges see? Civil orders can be issued with lower standards than criminal convictions. That smells like punish‑first, explain‑later — not justice. If the mayor wants criminals off the street, go after them with arrests and real prosecutions, not temporary court orders that opponents will tie up in appeals.
What Seattle should do instead
Start with simple common sense. Fund real prosecutions and give officers the tools to arrest and hold traffickers. Coordinate with the King County prosecutors who handle felony trafficking cases. Close streets where crooks operate until police say it’s safe. And yes, provide shelters and outreach for victims — but do both. You can’t protect victims by pushing criminals into the shadows or by pretending a civil gun order is a substitute for a felony case. If the city wants fewer shootings, make arrests, build cases, and keep pressure on the people who create the market for trafficking.
Don’t confuse performative policy with public safety
Mayor Wilson is right that victims shouldn’t be pushed further into danger. But muddled policies that avoid holding traffickers accountable fail both victims and neighborhoods. Using ERPOs as a shortcut may win headlines and applause from the crowd that prefers clever legal workarounds to hard policing. It won’t stop the demand for prostitution, nor will it dismantle criminal networks. If Seattle really cares about Aurora Avenue and the people trapped there, it will fund prosecutors, back its police when they go after serious criminals, and shut down the business model that feeds trafficking — not just swap one set of temporary barriers for another.
