Pennsylvania is at a crossroads. U.S. Senator David McCormick this week sent a formal letter urging Governor Josh Shapiro to opt the commonwealth into the federal Education Freedom Tax Credit program — and he warned the “window of opportunity” is closing. With a firm federal filing deadline looming, this isn’t the time for more studies and committees; it’s the time for action that helps kids and parents now.
What the Education Freedom Tax Credit Means for Pennsylvania
How the program works
The Education Freedom Tax Credit is a federal tax break that rewards people who give money to Scholarship Granting Organizations, or SGOs. Donors get a dollar-for-dollar credit for contributions. SGOs turn that money into need-based K–12 scholarships that pay for things like tuition, tutoring and school supplies. Proponents say the program can reach a lot of families fast: one estimate puts about 1.8 million Pennsylvania students as eligible under the program’s income rules.
McCormick’s Case: Don’t Wait for Final Rules
Senator McCormick argues Pennsylvania already has experience with state tax-credit scholarship programs and does not need to wait on final federal regulations. He told the governor the benefits for students “could be substantial” and warned the clock is ticking on the Jan. 1 filing for states that want to participate in the program’s first year. Governor Shapiro has said he’s “very open” to the idea and that his agencies are reviewing guidance — which is sensible — but doing nothing until the last minute is not a plan. This is about giving parents options, not preserving process for process’s sake.
Union Pushback vs. Real Parent Power
Of course, teachers’ unions and some education groups are loudly opposed. They warn the program will drain money from public schools. Here’s the blunt rebuttal: this federal tax credit leverages private donations to expand choices for needy families — it doesn’t force state tax dollars out the door. If donors step up, more kids get opportunities without Congress writing a blank check to any one system. If defenders of the education status quo want to keep a public monopoly, they should at least be honest about it instead of pretending this is about protecting children.
Final Word: Governor Shapiro Should Opt In
Pennsylvania has a short runway to opt in for 2027. Republican lawmakers and school-choice advocates are pushing hard, and the facts favor moving quickly to give parents real options. Governor Shapiro can take a politically sensible, pro-family step that helps low-income children now. Or he can let deadlines pass, hand the issue to the legislature, and watch families wait. The choice is obvious — and voters will remember who stood with parents and who stood with the bureaucracy.
