Journalist Zaid Jilani lit up X this week with a long thread arguing that Americans put too much of their genocide education weight on the Holocaust. The post drew a quick Community Note correction and loud pushback from other reporters. The online dustup tells us more about social‑media showmanship than it does about history — but it also reopened a real debate about what schools teach and why.
What happened on X
Jilani’s thread said the Holocaust only became central to American memory after 1970s TV and films, and that other genocides get short shrift. That is a fair prompt for a curriculum debate. The problem came in the tone. A senior reporter at The Washington Free Beacon dismissed the thread with a savage one‑liner that went viral. X also attached a Community Note disputing the idea that the Holocaust is merely a media construction. In other words: the claim was provocative, the correction was swift, and the argument landed in a pile of hot takes.
Why the Holocaust holds a special place
No one should pretend the Holocaust isn’t different in scale, planning and global reach. That is not a partisan point. Nazi Germany mounted an industrial, bureaucratic campaign to exterminate entire peoples across occupied territories. That was not the same kind of violence as every other atrocity in history, and scholars rightly warn against sloppy comparisons that erase those facts. At the same time, historians note that a 1970s TV miniseries did accelerate public awareness in the U.S. So Jilani’s basic historical touch — that media helped raise attention — has a grain of truth. The mistake was sounding like he wanted to downgrade the suffering rather than broaden our memory.
We can teach the Holocaust and teach more
Here’s the honest, practical answer: America should teach both. Schools should keep the Holocaust central because it shows how state power, law and propaganda can be weaponized. They should also teach Rwanda, the Armenian deportations, Indonesia and other mass killings so students learn patterns and warning signs. This isn’t zero‑sum. Expanding curriculum takes actual work — better standards, teacher training, and textbooks that treat genocide as a global problem, not a quiz question. The online theatrics don’t help that effort one bit.
The real test is what happens in classrooms
If this Twitter row proves anything, it’s that loud takes spread fast but change is slow. Call out overstated hot takes when they deserve it. Call for better genocide education too. Parents and taxpayers should demand curricula that teach history honestly — including both the unique horror of the Holocaust and the lessons of other mass atrocities. That would make students smarter, not pious, and it would put social‑media sniping back to where it belongs: in the comments.

