The Supreme Court quietly declined to take up Trump v. Thakur, leaving in place lower-court orders that blocked the White House from canceling certain University of California research grants tied to DEI, climate, and gender topics. The court’s refusal is not a ruling on the law. It is a decision to let the 9th Circuit and a federal judge keep control for now — and that matters for federal spending, free speech, and how Washington runs science programs.
Supreme Court punts on Trump v. Thakur
By refusing review, the Supreme Court left a district-court injunction and parts of a 9th Circuit ruling intact. Those lower-court decisions said the government likely crossed a line by targeting grants because of their topics or viewpoints. The Justice Department, arguing for the administration, said agencies should be able to set funding priorities and cut projects that run counter to policy. The result: the administration’s effort to cancel many awards remains blocked while legal fights play out.
Why judges stopped the funding cancellations
Viewpoint protection and the Administrative Procedure Act
U.S. District Judge Rita Lin and the 9th Circuit focused on how the terminations were done. The record shows agencies used form letters, keyword searches, and lists of forbidden terms to pull grants. Courts said that looks like viewpoint discrimination and may be arbitrary under the Administrative Procedure Act. In plain language: you can set priorities, but you can’t cancel already awarded grants in a way that targets a point of view or treats winners like they don’t deserve a reasoned explanation.
What this means for President Trump’s agenda and federal research funding
President Trump has a clear policy preference against DEI and related topics, and a right to set spending priorities. But the way the administration tried to implement that policy opened it to legal trouble. The government originally pointed to a big dollar figure — over $300 million — though the immediate contested pot had shrunk by the time of the petition. Courts are saying process matters: if you want to change what gets funded, do it by rules and not by blunt, after-the-fact cancellations that look like ideological litmus tests.
Fix the process, not just the politics
The Supreme Court’s decision to leave the lower-court rulings in place is a warning to both sides. For conservatives who want spending aligned with priorities, the lesson is to use proper rulemaking and clear grant criteria. For universities and researchers, the ruling reaffirms First Amendment protections against viewpoint-based punishment. If Washington wants lasting change, Congress and agencies should craft clean, defensible rules instead of relying on form letters and keyword sweeps. Otherwise this messy fight will keep landing back in court.

