admin
Just The News reports a fresh and troubling development: Senate leaders are sitting on records the Justice Department says it needs in the criminal probe of former CIA Director John Brennan. The DOJ asked Senate committees for fully unredacted transcripts and materials tied to the 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment and the Steele dossier. Months after a February deadline, that paperwork has not been handed over — and the story says Senate Majority Leader John Thune and Senator Tom Cotton are the ones slowing the transfer.
What Just The News reported
The reporting says DOJ formally asked the Senate Intelligence and Judiciary committees for unredacted transcripts, depositions, briefings and written responses related to Brennan. Prosecutors were given a February 23 deadline and, according to the story, were only allowed to read one report in a secure room. Meanwhile, the House already moved comparable material to DOJ. The new wrinkle is that this is not a Democratic roadblock — it’s Republican Senate leadership choosing unanimous consent instead of a public floor vote, a choice that lets any single senator quietly halt the transfer.
Why this matters
This is not a partisan parlor game. Prosecutors are running a grand-jury inquiry into whether former officials lied about the ICA and whether intelligence tools were weaponized against civilians. If the Senate really wants oversight to mean anything, it should not be treating requested evidence like a museum piece to be ogled under a glass box. The optics are awful: a GOP-led Senate sitting on evidence that a GOP Justice Department says it needs to pursue potential crimes. That invites the very charge of protectionism conservatives should despise.
Why Thune and Cotton should release the records
Senate Majority Leader John Thune and Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman Tom Cotton owe the country a simple answer. Thune’s deference to procedure has a limit when investigators say they need classified transcripts to examine possible criminal conduct. And Cotton, who built a reputation railing against intelligence abuse, should know that hoarding material because it’s awkward is not the same as defending principle. If you referred Brennan for criminal review, you don’t then shelter the files that prove the case. That kind of two-step dance looks worse than an honest fight.
What DOJ should do next
Compulsory process is available and appropriate
If voluntary cooperation stalls — which appears to be happening — the Justice Department has tools. Grand-jury subpoenas and compulsory process can compel the transfer of classified committee records. Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche should make a clear choice: negotiate for cooperation, or issue the subpoena that moves the process forward. Leadership can avoid a public vote, but prosecutors can’t be expected to rely on good manners when evidence is at stake.
Republicans who care about accountability should stop pretending decorum is a higher virtue than law. If Thune and Cotton have legitimate security or legal reasons, say so and show the papers that justify holding them. If not, quit the charade, release the transcripts, or face the predictable charge that the party put politics above justice. The country — and conservative credibility — deserve better than shadowy delay.
